The Rollins Drama

Rollins: We'll Win 100 GamesIs this just the beginning of the Jimmy Rollins drama?

ESPN’s Buster Olney had a very interesting tweet and story today about Rollins, who was benched three consecutive games last week because Ryne Sandberg had a problem with him:

Olney then noted, “Jimmy Rollins, of course, cannot be traded without his consent, because he has 10-5 rights.”

Yes, there are folks who have grown tired of Rollins. But then the Phillies also signed him to a three-year, $33 million extension following the 2011 season, despite no evidence any other team in baseball offered him more than a one-year deal. Rollins’ deal includes an easily attainable club option for 2015, which essentially makes this a four-year, $44 million contract. The Phillies handed him this contract, despite knowing his shortcomings, knowing they had Freddy Galvis waiting in the wings and knowing Rollins’ production had declined the previous three seasons. His .720 OPS from 2009-11 ranked 144th out of 181 qualifying players, and 14th out of 25 qualifying shortstops.

They committed big money to him anyway.

Two important things to remember here:

1. Rollins has the power. Don’t forget that. He has 10-and-5 rights, so he can reject any trade at any time for any reason. He has made that perfectly clear repeatedly over the past year. Talking about a potential fire sale last season, he said in May it would be strange not to see Chase Utley at second base. I reminded Rollins that he could be traded, but only if he accepted. He smiled and said, “Yeah, I’ve got the juice.” He reiterated that stance in July, when he said he would not waive his trade rights because he wanted to pursue some personal records, including the franchise’s hits record.

He said the same thing again last month,

“I don’t plan on putting on a different uniform,” Rollins said. “That’s just the way it is. I could say it that way. I could say I’ve got work I need to do. I could say I’ve got records I need to break. I could say I want to win another World Series or two. They would love that because it’s said the way they want to hear it. But we weren’t going to win a World Series last year, so I couldn’t make that statement at that moment. It doesn’t matter how it’s said. I really don’t plan on putting on another uniform. If I say something wrong, get on me. If I speak the truth, you can get on me, but it’s not going to bother me. That’s the thing. I’m straightforward. I’ll be politically correct because I have to be at times, but I’m straightforward.”

And, yes, Rollins repeated himself once more just the other day to

The Phillies have tried the previous two trade deadlines and offseasons to move him, but does he sound like a guy who wants to be traded? Does he sound like a guy who would even entertain the thought?

2. The Phillies are expected to have a franchise-record payroll come Opening Day. Whether or not anybody thinks this team is going to be any good — there are plenty of signs this spring that suggest otherwise — the Phillies have committed a ton of money to their roster, so they are going to try to win. People love Galvis’ glove, but some remain unconvinced he can hit big-league pitching on a regular basis. And while Rollins is coming off the worst year of his career, some still think he can bounce back (along with Ryan Howard, Chase Utley, Carlos Ruiz, etc.) and provide enough production to put this team into postseason contention. It might be a long shot, but in some ways it would make little sense to try and trade Rollins now.

Not that Rollins would accept a trade anyway.

Rollins needs 434 plate appearances to have his club option automatically vest. This is a layup, if he is healthy. Couldn’t the Phillies put the screws to him and tell him they plan to split time at shortstop between him and Galvis? I suppose they could, but it seems unlikely. (Rollins said last week he hasn’t even thought about that possibility.) Push aside frustrations regarding Rollins for a moment. He is the greatest shortstop in franchise history. He helped the team win just its second World Series championship in franchise history. He won a National League MVP Award in 2007. He is a former All-Star, Gold Glover and Silver Slugger winner. He works in the community and has the most tenure of any professional athlete in Philadelphia. For those reasons, and knowing how Phillies president David Montgomery runs his business — he appreciates what Rollins has meant to the organization as much or more than anybody — I would be surprised if the Phillies tried a tactic like this.

But this whole thing really comes back to production. The Phillies turned a blind eye to Rollins’ faults in the past when he put up big offensive numbers. Eh, so he doesn’t always run hard to first. Eh, so he seems indifferent at times. The guy produces. But now that Rollins isn’t producing there is less tolerance, and more people expressing their frustrations, whether it’s a pointed “no comment” from Sandberg when asked about Rollins’ influence this spring or sources in Olney’s story.

Sandberg sent Rollins a clear message last week. Could the Phillies be trying to send another? Or is this just the wishful thinking of a Phillies front office executive? Remember, front offices discuss countless scenarios, the majority of which never come close to fruition. Regardless of what anybody feels or desires, the Phillies and Rollins are going to continue their relationship into the season. I would bet on it.


I read that part of this issue is that Sandberg wants Rollins to step up, and be more of a leader. Something, I guess, Sandberg doesn’t see him doing, with comments he’s made lately. Why worry about him being the team leader? I’ve heard over, and over, that the players consider Chase their team leader. By his actions, not his words. Maybe Sandberg wants someone more vocal.

Team leader–overrated. Ryne Sandberg was asked by Mike Missanelli on his radio sport talk show about the “team leader.” Sandberg said, essentially, that leadership starts with himself. He is the manager and it is his job to lead and motivate the team. This flows to the coaches to teach and lead. The players listen, learn and play and for that they are paid BIG MONEY.
The biggest problem the Phillies have is the GM–Amaro. The Phillies are constantly trying to play around his mistakes.

If they really wanted to trade Rollins all they would have to do is bench him for say a month, I would think Rollins would be acceptable to a trade. Ozzie Smith wasn’t going anywhere either when a new manager took over the Cardinals. I hope it doesn’t come to that. I hope Rollins has a big year and I hope the Phillies will winn big this year. That being said, goodbye Jimmy

I think it’s what Ryne DOESN’T want–which is a questionable attitude from an overpaid, once-great SS who likely can’t lead or produce now. With a mostly new team, new coaches, and an intent on a new era, smug smiling isn’t the attitude for winning or moving on. But it’s what Rollins should do if he is the professional he says he is. Who will proclaim his records or think well on him if he finishes this way?? Staying undercuts what he’s done–leaving puts a “less selfish” tag on him that he has rarely worn. But he’s NOT moving on, so……the conclusion is evident.


Regardless of how you feel about Rollins, Sandberg’s “no comment” comment tells me all I need to know about him. He’s an authoritarian, passive aggressive jerk and while that might work in AAA, I don’t see that working in the majors. You don’t discipline a veteran and not talk to him! I’ve had bosses like that. Wish he would’ve gone to Chicago.

had very high hopes for ryno. i was over the charlie manuel era. hoping for youthful, vigorous leadership from a HoF player.

this thing with jimmy has been so disappointing. mia was on it about his “no comment” thing. just pathetic passive aggressive nonsense.

and why not communicate to your player for days about your problem, and let the espn industrial complex blow everything out of proportion in the meantime? clear failure of leadership.

jimmy is the greatest ss in phils history. if he and chase are in the lineup on a balmy summer night, i will pay for a ticket.

i will NOT pay to see freddy galvis. did we forget he is a roider who lied when he got caught? correct me if i’m wrong zolecki. the reaction from the phils brass on that was way more tepid than this rollins drama. just embarrassing.

#11 will be retired one day in philly, no doubt

A bigger issue, in my opinion, is the source in the front office, which points to a bigger organizational concern.

Between this leak, reporting the unsigned draftees to the NCAA and all the rumors about trading Lee, Hamels & Papelbon during the winter meetings… the Phillies are suddenly in the gossip section a lot more frequently than I remember in the past.

All of these contracts and/or character issues that are weighing down the franchise are the direct result of Amaro’s decisions in composing the roster; however, I think these leaks (assuming they are not coming from the GM) hurt the team’s ability to move players more than it helps.

The gossip takes away leverage by painting the team as desperate & motivated to make a deal, ensuring we will not got a fair return at all.

Sort of sick of all of this. Agreed, that the issue is more with Ryan Sanberg. After all these years, JR isn’t going to be the clubhouse leader. I believe that belongs to either Utley or Hamels. Let’s see what Jimmy does this year. Yup, he does have records HE wants to break. so what, he is the only one that can break them. Galvis cannot fill his shoes nor should they try it. Let’s play out the year and see what happens but I think this is a big issue because 1) media is making it a bigger issue and 2) perhaps Sanberg isn’t quite that loved. are we dealing with another “no comment” Any Reid attitude type coach?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: