Everybody Surprised Hernandez Tossed, Except Umps

Roberto HernandezNobody seemed more surprised that Roberto Hernandez got ejected in the sixth inning last night at Citizens Bank Park than Hernandez.

Or maybe it was Ryne Sandberg.

Or maybe it was Starlin Castro and players and coaches from both the Phillies and Cubs clubhouses. Or every fan in the ballpark.

Home plate umpire Mark Ripperger, who is a Triple-A call up, ejected Hernandez almost immediately after he threw a first-pitch fastball that ran inside to hit Castro, who homered against him in the fourth inning of a 2-1 Cubs victory. It was a 2-0 game with two outs in the sixth and Hernandez had thrown just 81 pitches as he hoped to pitch past the sixth inning for just the third time in 12 starts this season.

“I was very, very surprised,” Hernandez said. “I didn’t throw that on purpose. I had two outs. I wanted to pitch into the next inning.”

Castro and Cubs manager Rick Renteria agreed.

“I don’t think he did it on purpose,” Castro said. “He’s a good friend of mine. I know him a lot. I see him every day in the Dominican. I was surprised because I don’t even know why the umpire threw him out for that. It was the same pitch as the homer. That ball ran in because he doesn’t have control.”

“I don’t think they were trying to hit Starlin,” Renteria said. “I think the ball got away from the kid.”

Crew chief Gary Cederstrom spoke briefly to a pool reporter after the game, barely looking up from his newspaper as he talked.

“I thought the appropriate action was taken,” Cederstrom said.

Why was Hernandez ejected?

“Intentionally throwing at the batter,” he said.

How did he know that? Was he reading his mind?

“That’s our job,” he said.

Ryne Sandberg jogged onto the field in disbelief. Ripperger ejected Sandberg shortly thereafter.

“Quick toss of the pitcher with no warning,” Sandberg said. “Well, there were some other pitches inside the rest of the game and even early on in the game. Hernandez did not have his control throughout the game. I think that has to go noticed by an umpire. Typically there’s a warning there if he thinks he did it on purpose. There was no way it was on purpose.”


I am sure Larry Bowa does not have a problem when Ryno is ejected since he assumes the managerial position. Which is fine with me since I think Bowa passionately wants to win.

Gary Cederstrom is a smug, arrogant jerk, and this had better show up in his performance ratings by MLB. You can even see in slow motion the reaction of Hernandez as he realizes it got away. You stink, Cederstrom.

Todd, we’ve already argued about this on twitter. But if the claim is the umpire couldn’t read Hernandez’ mind, that’s an argument for tossing him, since Castro was the only batter Roberto hit. The lack of control claim from Ryne is therefore a little silly. Umpires can’t read minds, so if a guy is hit exactly one AB after hitting a HR, it’s hardly unreasonable to toss the guy. I’m not saying Roberto should have been ejected.

The proper action would have been to issue a warning. Hernandez does not have a history of retaliation as some do Ejecting him is very unreasonable! You do not have to be a mind reader to see a pitcher’s control is not up to par — especially if you are the home plate umpire. A case of OVER REACTION!!

You can see Roberto throw his hands up when it happened. There was no reason for him to hit Castro, and he’s never been known for his pinpoint control. Why not just issue a warning? Cederstrom’s even worse for backing the play.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: